The Dead
The Dead
In "The Dead" by James Joyce, the
characters, the symbol and other factors all add up to give the readers an idea
of paralysis of emotion or passion in people's lives. Gabriel, the main
character, is emotionally dead and tainted in the secular society. The first
evidence is that he has never truly loved his wife, Gretta; his attraction
towards his wife was a mere fascination to a desire to control her. When
Gabriel "watched her while she slept, as though he and she had never lived
together as man and wife," he cried, thinking "he had never felt like
how Michael Furry did towards any woman." This shows that he is
emotionally dead, never having truly loved his wife at least and most of the
women he had met in his life. Also, Gabriel shows such an arrogant and
disdainful attitude to others, as seen by his behavior at the annual party:
"Gabriel took his seat boldly at the head of the table and, having looked
to the edge of the carver, plunged his fork firmly into the goose. He felt
quite at ease now, for he was an expert carver and liked nothing better than to
find himself at the head of a well-laden table." Such attitude makes him
disconnected with the rest of the population, which makes him become
"dead" to others. Furthermore, he tries to solve problems using the power
of money, immediately giving some tips to the caretaker's daughter, Lily, when
she got annoyed by Gabriel's words. This behavior of his shows that he is too
tainted in the materialistic world and is emotionally deprived.
The death of Michael Furry too represents
the absence of passion in people's lives. According to the description in the
story, he had lived a passionate life and lived fully, probably doing what he
truly wanted, with great enthusiasm. Thus, the death may signify the death of
such passion in their lives.
Apart from these two characters, others,
especially those in the party seem to live the lives of deadening routines.
Every year, the Morkan's party takes place, with the same events happening
every year: Gabriel gives a speech, Freddy Malins arrives to the party drunk,
everyone dances in the same routine steps, and everyone eats while chats. No
one thinks of opening a different-colored party or doing something else than
attending party to associate with people and eat. This state is similar to the
anecdote told by Gabriel with the horse that circles around and around the
mill.
In the story, the symbol of
"snow" plays an important role in conveying the theme of the
"dead" mentioned above. At the very last part of the story, Gabriel
watches snow covering the whole village, touching both the dead and the living,
including the grave of Michael Furry.
In spite of the theme of death covering the
whole story, the author does try to lead the readers into thinking of a
breakage of such theme. The snow melts someday, meaning the whole village that
was covered by snow quietly will break its silence someday. Furthermore,
epiphany came on to Gabriel; he realized that he doesn't have the actual power
to control his wife's feelings and that he should no longer deny the past. He
encounters such epiphany after talking to his wife who recalled the memory of
Michael Furry, her ex-lover.
Both the title and the story itself seem to
reflect the modern society quite thoroughly, since we are locked up in the same
routines every day, living our lives with less passion and emotion than we did
in the past, just as people in the Morkan's party. If anyone tries to get out
of the system or of the norm, he or she must bear losing jobs, breaking
relationship or get into lots of other troubles.
Of course, living in the routine is stable
in terms of both personal level and societal level, since the stable system is
important in developing a society gradually. However, it becomes a problem the
routine system starts to lock up people's mind and body. This problem is
particularly severe in Korea, with people blaming you for deviating from the
norm even just a little bit. People expect similar ability, personality or
outer appearance from everybody, making those who are out of the standards
disabled or "weird" people. Little children who are repeatedly
imprinted with such "names" lose confidence, often becoming
psychologically disordered or going through difficulties without any reason.
Such stereotypes led to tremendous popularity of plastic surgery, especially in
Korea with the highest rate of plastic surgeries every year in OECD countries.
This phenomenon is, again, due to the people's expectations of similar,
beautiful outer appearance. Actually, if you walk across the Gangnam city for
just 30 minutes while observing the faces of women in their 20s or 30s, you can
easily notice that most of them have similar faces, just as the products mass manufactured
in factories. There are tons of other examples as well. Korea is one of the
countries with shortest period of fashion trend change.
This stereotype, or perhaps, culture, that
people want to play in the same routine and be like everybody else is actually
psychologically inevitable. Moreover, humans are social animals, so it is
natural that people desire to follow each other. Nevertheless, the state the
stereotype has gone too much and almost to an irreversible degree in the modern
society. The reason why it is especially a critical problem in Korea is the
culture; the culture makes us disabled if we don't follow the majority.
Usually, people don't respect distinctiveness of individuals. If anyone tries
wearing a quite different style of clothes than anybody else, if anyone looks
quite different from others, or if anyone behaves in a different way, people
immediately start to talk in whispers to each other, insult in the face or even
take photographs.
The most representative example that shows
our stereotypes is an example of glasses in Korean society. In my parents'
generation, those who wore glasses or had bad eyesight were considered "disabled."
If anyone shows up in public with glasses on, people used to pick on him or
her, even including the teachers and friends. However, since then, the average
eyesight of Korean population has been getting worse as people started to
encounter a lot of electronic devices such as television, cell phones and
computers, as well as establishing bad habits. Eventually, more and more people
are wearing glasses and no one calls someone disabled just for wearing glasses.
Those who cannot use their legs are
considered handicapped because there are more people whose legs work properly,
and those with hearing impairment are considered disabled because there exist
more people whose ears work properly.
As "the dead" tells us, we should
no longer try to be similar with others, or live indistinct lives. Instead, we
should sometimes make decisions that are out of the norm if you think it is
right.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteGood job. More than a bit long, you extensively cover elements of story that contribute to "snow being general all over" society. The metaphor extends to Korea, and the examples you produce are solid. That said, you could keep the threads dealing with The Dead alive during the latter discussion, as it feels disconnected. Anyways, really well written in some spots, and much better in the first half. Towards the end you seem to get a bit random, and lose focus. Those last two paragraphs look like afterthoughts, and your conclusion is weak. Try to balance the consistency, and don't introduce more than needed if you aren't going to use the examples thoroughly. I'd say the last 4 paragraphs feel unnecessary.
ReplyDeleteBesides this complaint of going overboard, the literary analysis is good.