Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Packaged Flowers





The owner of these beautiful flowers must have packed them into a pretty box to make it look even more splendid. Sadly, their beauty is covered by a very plain box.
I felt sorry for the flowers because they aren't allowed to grow, now that they're cut off from their body. Furthermore, they're beauty cannot shine anymore. I was staring at this picture thinking this stuff when suddenly my neighbor, Hyun-Hee came into my head.

Hyun-Hee was an 11-year-old girl who was in my class and lived next door. She was a girl not unlike everybody else, who loved to play dolls with her friends, loved reading fairy tale stories and playing outside on the weekends. The only difference she had from her peers was that she was always on the top on every exam in my class. Nobody saw her studying in our classroom, but she was exceptional in terms of grades. I was curious how she had managed to be such a great student even though she didn't have any special feature. And as I was living next door, I found out the secret eventually; her mother was the strictist person I had ever encountered. I could hear her mother yelling at her daughter everyday, possibly because she wanted her to study more and get better grades. Hyun-Hee's schedule was like that of a celebrity. She had a bunch of academies and tutors coming over helping her to study more and more. Hyun-Hee seemed to be really stressed out from this, and one day…

We were playing hide and seek and riding bicycles in the backyard of our apartment, and when I suggested we go home now that it’s getting darker, she came over to me and suddenly started crying. I was utterly shocked at her sudden behavior, and I didn’t know what to say. All I could do was to stare at her vaguely waiting for her to say something.  Half crying, she told me these shocking stuff. For a few days, she stayed up all night trying to figure out the answers of the math problems she couldn’t figure out. She was dozing all night, but her mom kept waking her up, making her get the correct answers before she sleeps. She didn’t want to go home, because everyday, her mom yells at her for playing for so long and not studying enough.

Now, she ended up in a normal high school, being a normal student with normal grades. Now that I’m thinking about her, what her mother was trying to do was to pack a bunch of beautiful flowers in a plain box, labeled “beautiful flowers.” She should have let her go free and let her be the one who decides on her things. She should have let her do things she liked. She should have let the beautiful flowers blossom freely and express their own beauty and talent they were born with. Instead, she wrapped up her talent and her own characteristics with the “standardized features” by giving her so much stress an 11-year-old couldn’t possibly bear.

What I’m trying to say here is that, the real beauty can only be achieved, and a leader of a community can only be reared, by letting the children’s natural talents shine, not by oppressing them with unmanagable workloads.





2 comments:

  1. Off to a good start. You may want to poetically describe the photo a bit more - to get the reader to see it from your point of view. You have 500 words to play with and can really drive home your impressions.

    Curious to see where this goes.

    ReplyDelete
  2. SOME MINOR REVISIONS:


    The owner of these beautiful flowers must have packed them into a pretty box to make THEM look even more splendid. Sadly, their beauty is covered by a very plain box.

    (The sentence below - consider the tense. Feel or felt? Aren't or weren't? Should it be past or present? Do you still feel this way about the picture? If past, talk about the moment more. When and where and why did you see this picture? In any case BE CONSISTENT with verb tenses.)

    I felt sorry for the flowers because they aren't allowed to grow, now that they're cut off from their body. Furthermore, they're beauty cannot shine anymore. I was staring at this picture thinking this stuff when suddenly my neighbor, Hyun-Hee came into my head.


    Half crying, she told me SOME shocking THINGS. SHE DESCRIBED HOW she'd stayed up all night FOR A FEW DAYS trying to figure out the (DELETE answers of the) math problems (DELETE she couldn’t figure out). She was dozing all night, but her mom kept waking her up, making her get the correct answers before she SLEPT. She didn’t want to go home, because everyday, her mom YELLED at her for playing for so long and not studying enough.

    Now, she ended up in a normal high school, being a normal student with normal grades. Now that I’m thinking about her, what her mother was trying to do was to pack a bunch of beautiful flowers in a plain box, labeled “beautiful flowers.” She should have let her go free and let her be the one who TO DECIDE HER OWN PASSIONS (DELETE decides on her things). She should have let her do things she liked. She should have let the beautiful FLOWER blossom freely TO express THE beauty and talent SHE WAS born with. Instead, she wrapped up her talent and her own characteristics with the “standardized features” (DELETE by giving her so much) AND stress THAT an 11-year-old couldn’t possibly bear.

    _____________________________


    Good essay. It almost works as a speech as well. You could use a picture and hold it up, and this would definitely work as motivational and inspirational.

    There are many things I like about this essay, including the message. It also has a very good structure with the bookends (intro and conclusion well connected). You tell a good story, and I was able to flow from one paragraph to the next with ease. Everything is well controlled and neatly arranged - like flowers. Good intuition and choices made.

    Things that could improve: it's not so much an essay about "you." Nor is it dealing with a picture you took. The moment where you supposedly see this picture and think about your friend - very brief and lacking in detail for an essay that's about a photo that means a lot to you. It's a good essay, but maybe not the best fit for this assignment. I know I said you guys could use "any photo" - and you aren't breaking any rules. But the essay sort of drifts away from the prompt.

    All in all, very good, and you'll get a "good" score. If you want to write another one with a more intimate direction and personal photo (anytime between now and the end of the semester), you are welcome to do so. You've been doing some extra writing lately, so I keep that in mind for an "extra post."

    ReplyDelete